From “Neighbors With Benefits” to Court Dates: How Reality TV Keeps Confusing Attention for Accountability
There are celebrity scandals, and then there are stories that feel like they fell through a trapdoor in the American attention economy and landed somewhere far darker than the usual tabloid swamp. The arrest of Tony McCollister—once a blink-and-you-miss-it reality-TV figure—belongs firmly in the latter category. According to reporting, McCollister, a former participant on A&E’s short-lived 2015 series Neighbors With Benefits , has been charged in Ohio with pandering obscenity involving a minor and sexual conduct with an animal. Authorities confirmed that pets were confiscated during the investigation and are currently being cared for. McCollister has posted bail, been ordered to have no contact with children or animals, and is due back in court. His former spouse has stated they are no longer married. Those are the facts as publicly reported. Everything beyond that remains for the courts to determine. But the facts alone raise a more uncomfortable question—one that goes far beyo...