Why Americans Quietly Walk Away From Religion (And Why the Ones Who Stay Are Often More Certain Than Ever)
There’s a comforting myth Americans like to tell themselves about religion: that people either “lose faith” because they’re rebellious, lazy, or corrupted by TikTok—or they stay religious because they never really questioned anything in the first place. It’s a tidy story. It’s also deeply wrong. The data paints a messier, more human picture. According to new Pew Research Center findings, more than one-third of U.S. adults no longer identify with the religion they were raised in, while a solid majority still do. This isn’t a story of collapse versus loyalty. It’s a story of meaning, belief, disillusionment, drift, and timing—and above all, experience. Most people who leave don’t storm out in protest. They fade. Most people who stay don’t do so out of habit. They believe. And that distinction matters far more than America’s culture-war narratives want to admit. The Big Sorting: Who Stays, Who Leaves, and Why This Isn’t a Culture-War Headline Let’s start with the headline number everyone ...